Multi-location Cafe · Mission-Driven Roaster · 2025
Talitha
Refocusing a stretched national DTC budget into a local, compounding growth system.
- Client
- Talitha Coffee (formerly The WestBean Coffee Roasters)
- Location
- San Diego, CA
- Industry
- Multi-location cafe & specialty coffee roaster — mission-driven
- Service
- Community Growth Engine
- Engagement
- February 2025 – Present
01 — Snapshot
The Main Problem: trying to become a nationwide, direct-to-consumer coffee brand (without the organic budget)
Problem
Talitha had ambitions to become a nationwide direct-to-consumer coffee brand, but like many startup brands, lacked the organic budget to win nationally. Their spend was thinly spread across the country with little ROI to show for it.
Omni Common’s Solution
We concentrated their budget locally, where we predicted it would compound.
We invested in their San Diego cafes and the Talitha brand. The idea was that local inertia would lift the entire business more efficiently. DTC ecommerce growth followed as a by-product. (Plus, the one deliberately non-local lever, influencer marketing, became the single biggest driver of that online growth.)
Despite Talitha’s marketing engine being shared across three business lines — retail cafes, DTC ecommerce, and wholesale — the local investment lifted the entire company, not just the cafes. (The trick was investing into each one at the right level.)
+33%
Cafe average order value
+9%–12% at all three cafe locations post-rebrand.
+16%
Repeat customer revenue
From $63,600 to $73,600 per month.
+21%
Q1 2026 vs Q1 2025 cafe sales
70%–82% of post-rebrand customers were entirely new to the brand.
+343%
Brand reach YoY (April)
Built on ~29 press placements from a starting point of effectively zero earned media.
+571%
DTC ecommerce orders
Revenue roughly doubled (~+100%) from January 2025. Driven largely by influencer marketing.
+80%
Unique subscribers
Active subscriptions +66% across 2025. Site held ~3.7% conversion rate.
02 — Background
Strong Brand Messaging, and What the Budget Was Buying
Talitha Coffee was created with a strong commitment to philanthropy, sporting a marketing message to match: end human trafficking. It’s coffee with a purpose that socially-conscious customers genuinely care about.
Armed with award-winning blends — including a Global Coffee Awards honorable mention for their “Arise” roast — Talitha had both a good product and a great marketing message. What they lacked was a marketing engine to match.
03 — Approach
Focus the Budget Locally, Then Compound
We calculated that a dollar invested on building brand gravity locally would do more, and compound further, than a dollar invested nationally.
Rather than chasing the whole country on a budget that ultimately wouldn’t build their brand, we hyper-concentrated Talitha’s spend on the San Diego metro, where marketing exposure across cafes, local events, media placements and local search could stack and reinforce. (What we additionally discovered was that DTC ecommerce resulted far more quickly than anticipated!)
At the center of our local investment was the Community Growth Engine.
Every event we developed became fuel for every other marketing channel: social content, a PR hook, an influencer moment, and coordinated email and text… all resulting from one event! And because community growth was shared across Talitha’s cafes, DTC ecommerce, and wholesale, we could invest in each at one level, lifting all three at the same time.
Here’s what happened:
Community Development: The Engine
We amped up Talitha’s in-person presence all across San Diego. Over 12 months, we executed 49 (!) Talitha-branded events: booth appearances, coffee donations, sponsorships, and unique in-cafe gatherings. These reached an estimated 74,000+ people.
How does a marketing agency run events? Smartly, of course; we coordinated full-funnel campaigns with social countdowns, Facebook events, targeted email blasts, and outreached to local schools and businesses.
We also built an event-operations infrastructure from scratch: partnership screening and engagement, day-of logistics, Square POS coupon tracking, and ROI that was measured all the way back to each cash register.
Social Media
The brand’s pre-existing content consisted mostly of polished stock-style imagery. We rebuilt Talitha’s content engine to be centered around memorable brand traits, leaning on people-first storytelling (e.g., founder interviews, barista and event spotlights, etc.).
Talitha events became a content flywheel; every Talitha booth, product launch, and cafe moment was converted into social content.
Local SEM, SEO & Website
When Omni Common began, Talitha’s cafes had effectively no local SEO.
So we built their local SEO signals from the ground up: Google Business Profile optimization across all cafe locations, Apple Maps listings, SMS and email review campaigns for Google and Yelp, BrightLocal citation building per location, neighborhood city pages with embedded Google Maps, neighborhood blog content written by real locals, and a Homepage/About redesign that leads with the cafe and local brand story, rather than through a national ecommerce lens. Phew!
Mid-funnel? Email, Lifecycle & Paid Social
Talitha had discovery and checkouts. What was truly missing was the mid-funnel, so we built it.
We built an email marketing engine in Klaviyo + Square POS from scratch — not by touching their existing ecommerce flows, but by developing a content strategy around what we discovered Talitha customers actually wanted from the brand: insight into the mission, and how Talitha was making a difference.
All that content tied directly into the Community Growth Engine idea. We used email and SMS as a direct event-attendance acquisition channel, communicating loyalty promotions to encourage cafe visits with incentives and urgency, and we set up customer-review request flows. (Not to mention we also ran Paid social awareness-and-traffic campaigns, which drove Google Business Profile clicks at $0.12 CPC while reaching 25,000+ people per week.)
Digital PR
Our PR strategy focused on getting Talitha covered as a coffee brand with a mission, a meaningful differentiator.
This angle resulted in dozens of prominent news placements, including Travel + Leisure, The Manual, Perfect Daily Grind, Yahoo, MSN, and a live FOX 5 segment. We also designed and released a “San Diego State of Coffee” report consisting of proprietary data, positioning Talitha as a local industry voice.
Influencer Marketing: A DTC Growth Lever
Influencer marketing was our single exception to the all-local strategy. In fact, it became the single biggest driver of Talitha’s DTC ecommerce growth.
In one example, we landed and ran a flagship partnership with New York Times best-selling author and famed podcaster Jen Hatmaker, coordinating with her team across an ongoing campaign that drove hundreds of direct product sales. We knew that for a purpose-driven brand, the right creators don’t just sell things — they carry a mission to aligned audiences nationwide.
04 — Results
What Omni Common Accomplished
Where the budget went did exactly what our math said it would do.
Average order value rose +9%–12% at every one of their three locations (and +33% overall). Repeat customer revenue rose +16% ($63,600 → $73,600/month). Meanwhile, Q1 2026 cafe sales tracked 21% above Q1 2025, with 70%–82% of post-rebrand customers being entirely new to the brand.
Talitha also went from near-zero earned media to dozens of placements, with +343% reach growth YoY and ~30% brand recognition at the international 2025 Coffee Fest, incidentally held in San Diego that year.
Finally, DTC ecommerce also grew, even though it wasn’t the direct focus: national orders grew +571%, revenue roughly doubled from the start of the year, and their coffee subscription base grew +66% among active subscriptions and +80% among unique subscribers. In other words, because the marketing engine is shared across all their businesses, local investment fed their wholesale pipeline too.
Not bad for reallocating funds, if we say so ourselves.
+33%
Cafe AOV
+21%
Q1 2026 cafe sales
+571%
DTC ecommerce orders
+343%
Brand reach YoY
Services delivered
Metrics sourced from Shopify, Square POS, Klaviyo, Google Analytics, Google Search Console, BrightLocal, and Omni Common's integrated KPI dashboards (2024–2026). DTC ecommerce and subscription figures from the Talitha KPI dashboard; cafe and customer figures from the Talitha Master Growth Analysis (June 2026). All performance figures are expressed as relative change.
